The S-Corp Reasonable Salary: The Number That Keeps 1099 CRNAs Defensible
Adapted from Episode 12 of The Financial Cocktail podcast. Listen wherever you get your podcasts, or read the full episode below.
Every 1099 CRNA hears the same pitch. Elect S-Corp status, pay yourself a salary, take the rest as distributions, and save a pile on taxes.
What nobody tells you is how to pick the salary. That one number decides how much you save, how much you can put into your retirement accounts, and how exposed you are if the IRS ever comes asking.
That number has a name: the reasonable salary.
But first, let's get you set up.
The 13-Step 1099 CRNA Checklist
Going 1099 is mostly paperwork and planning. Here's the list I wish I'd had.
Decide if 1099 is right for you. Most locum work is 1099 by default. More and more full-time roles in the Southwest are 1099 only. Some places offer both.
Start your licensure early. RN (compact or non-compact), CRNA and DEA. State rules vary. Expect about three months to clear licensing plus facility credentialing.
Choose your entity, and don't overthink it. Most CRNAs can go sole proprietor: zero paperwork, same outcome. If you want an LLC, check your Secretary of State website to see whether your state requires a professional LLC (PLLC).
Elect S-Corp status, if it fits. The LLC is the entity. The S election is the tax treatment layered on top. More on this below.
Get an EIN. It's free and takes a few minutes directly from the IRS. Never pay a third party for it.
Find the right CPA. You want someone who already understands CRNA 1099 income, salary and distribution splits, and travel deductions. This should not be a learning journey for both of you. Ask coworkers for referrals.
Open a business bank account. Keep business and personal money fully separate, no exceptions. I put $10,000 in up front to cover housing and licensure. A couple of months later, once income was flowing, I took out exactly the same amount in one transaction. Clean records.
Get a business credit card. Same principle, cleaner expense trail. Some things will get mixed up. Sort them out fast.
Line up health insurance. This is the biggest new cost 1099 CRNAs underestimate. Your W-2 employer likely covers around 80% of your premium, so expect to pay roughly five times what you pay now. Our family pays about $28,000 a year for solid Blue Cross coverage with an HSA. Not cheap.
Replace your other benefits. Disability, life insurance, retirement. Nothing is automatic anymore. W-2 means someone handles it for you. Now you're on your own.
Secure malpractice coverage. Most contracts I've seen require $1 million / $3 million. I carry my own policy rather than leaning on a recruiter's. I want the attorneys working for me, not for the hospital or the agency.
Build one credentialing folder. CV, diploma, NBCRNA certificate, one to two years of case logs, malpractice certificates and references. Every time you renew something, like your AHA certifications or your flu shot, label it and drop it in. SRNAs: start this before you graduate. If you're credentialed at four or five facilities at once, you'll thank yourself.
Sign the contract, then book housing. In that order, and close together. We travel with kids and a dog, so hotels stopped working for us. Furnished Finder, Airbnb and some hospital housing have served us well.
That gets you in the door. Now for the part that keeps you there.
Why I Use an S-Corp (and Why You Might Not Need One)
I use an S-Corp for exactly two reasons.
First, my wife works for the business. Mrs. TFC has no W-2 job elsewhere, so working for our LLC lets her open her own retirement accounts through the business. And she earns it. She handles the accounting, the receipts, our CPA, the paperwork, the travel and the lodging. Every job offer the agency sends me goes through her first.
Second, health insurance. We relocate for assignments, so we need in-network coverage nationwide, and marketplace plans don't give us that. Our Blue Cross plan requires two or more employees. It no longer covers single-person groups.
Here's what I don't use it for: the corporate veil. Medical malpractice suits are personal. An LLC does you no good there. Other industries, maybe. Medicine, no.
If you don't share my two reasons, a sole proprietorship is probably your best setup. You get the same business expenses and deductions with far less hassle. It's a great conversation to have with your CPA.
Where the S-Corp Savings Actually Come From
The whole S-Corp pitch comes down to payroll taxes.
FICA is Social Security plus Medicare: 15.3% in total. High earners pay an extra 0.9% Medicare tax on wages over $200,000 single or $250,000 married filing jointly.
As a W-2 employee, your employer pays half (7.65%) and you pay the other half. As a 1099 sole proprietor, you pay all 15.3% yourself as self-employment tax.
An S-Corp splits your income into two buckets:
Salary, which carries the full payroll tax
Distributions, which owe federal and state income tax but no FICA at all
So the way to get payroll taxes to zero is simple: don't take a salary.
That's exactly what the IRS won't let you do. S-Corp owners who work in the business must pay themselves a "reasonable salary." The tax code doesn't define it. Some CPAs lean into the gray area. Others won't go near it. The more you understand it before you hire one, the better.
The Rules of Thumb
Here are the approaches I've heard CPAs and other providers use.
50–60% of net income. Net means after business expenses, so housing and travel reimbursements are left out. CRNAs don't buy big equipment or materials, so this tends to keep you out of trouble.
At or near the Social Security wage base. For 2026, that's $184,500. The 12.4% Social Security tax stops there: 12.4% × $184,500 = $22,878 for the year. Above that, the government doesn't collect more Social Security tax no matter how high your wages go. Medicare's 2.9% (plus the extra 0.9% for high earners) keeps going on every dollar. The thinking is that a salary near the cap gives the IRS most of what it's going to get anyway.
The hours split. Assume a 40-hour week: 35 or more clinical hours billed at a CRNA rate, plus two to five office hours billed at something like $20 an hour.
Every CPA will tell you something different. The first one I met wanted every dollar of income paid as salary. I told him I didn't think that's how it works. We didn't have a second meeting.
How Likely Is an Audit?
Very unlikely. Per the 2025 IRS Data Book, fewer than 0.05% of the roughly 5.25 million S-Corp returns filed for tax year 2022 were examined.
Does that mean you should cheat? No.
And it's getting easier for the IRS to spot problems. Officer compensation sits on its own line of Form 1120-S (line 7). Distributions are reported on Schedule K (line 16d). A $0 or token salary next to a six- or seven-figure distribution is a mismatch a machine can read. Once total receipts reach $500,000, officer pay is also itemized on Form 1125-E.
There's no safe harbor percentage. If you're examined, the burden of proof sits with your corporation, not the IRS.
When a Low Salary Backfires
Two court cases show what happens.
David E. Watson, P.C. v. United States (8th Cir. 2012). A CPA paid himself a $24,000 salary from his own accounting practice while taking distributions of $203,651 and $175,470 over two years. The government's expert set reasonable wages at $91,044. That added $67,044 a year to his taxable wages, plus penalties (Journal of Accountancy).
Joseph M. Grey Public Accountant, P.C. v. Commissioner (2002). The sole shareholder took a $0 salary for two years while doing substantial work and taking distributions. The Tax Court reclassified the distributions as wages.
Those cases point to three triggers:
A zero or token salary alongside real distributions in the same year
A sudden drop in salary paired with a jump in distributions
No documented basis for the number, even when the number itself is defensible
That third one is where most people go wrong.
If your salary is found too low, you owe the back payroll taxes plus penalties and interest from the original due dates. In practice, those penalties are often smaller than the savings. That's an ethics question, not a math one. Do it right.
Building a Defensible Number
The IRS lists factors it considers for reasonable compensation. For CRNAs, the ones that matter most are your training and experience, your duties, the time you devote to the business, your past pay and distribution history, and what comparable businesses pay for similar services.
One simple way to think about it: could you hire another CRNA to do your job for what you're paying yourself?
Where to find comparable pay data:
The AANA Compensation and Benefits Survey. Probably the most defensible source. It's a professionally run survey of our profession.
The Bureau of Labor Statistics. Its wage data lists nurse anesthetists under occupation code 29-1151, with mean pay and the 10th through 90th percentiles. It's the federal source the IRS is likely to reference.
A third-party reasonable compensation report. The best option if you want an examiner-ready file.
In the end, the habit matters most. Document why you chose your salary in the year you chose it, not after an audit letter arrives. It takes a little extra effort, and it lets both you and your CPA sleep at night.
The Salary Sets Your Retirement Ceiling
Here's where the salary feeds into your Solo 401(k).
The employee deferral for 2026 is $24,500. The employer profit-sharing contribution is up to 25% of your S-Corp W-2 wages, and the combined limit is $72,000 before catch-ups.
Take a full-time CRNA paying themselves a $160,000 salary:
Employee deferral: $24,500
Employer contribution (25% × $160,000): $40,000
Total: $64,500
That leaves $7,500 of room. If the plan allows after-tax contributions and in-plan Roth conversions, a mega backdoor Roth fills the gap with Roth dollars.
Now drop the salary to $80,000. The employee deferral is still $24,500, but the employer contribution falls to $20,000. That employer money is a business expense and goes in untaxed, so a low salary gives some of that up.
Too low a salary saves payroll tax but shrinks your retirement room and raises your audit exposure. Too high a salary costs you payroll tax you didn't need to pay and does little for your audit risk, since S-Corps are so rarely examined.
Most full-time 1099 CRNAs I see land somewhere between $80,000 and $184,500. Paying yourself above the Social Security wage base has little benefit. Part-time is a different comparison: a CRNA working 26 weeks a year can justify a lower salary than a full-time one.
Salary also affects your qualified business income (QBI) deduction. A low earner with a $0 salary and the full QBI deduction would be ideal, but that's not most CRNAs. Anesthesia is a specified service business, so higher earners phase out of QBI entirely. If you're a high-earning locum CRNA, QBI may not apply to you at all, no matter how often it shows up in the 1099 sales pitch. Another good topic for your CPA.
Case Study: How We Run Our S-Corp
Here's our actual rhythm.
Monthly, we run payroll through QuickBooks. I get paid, Mrs. TFC gets paid, and payroll taxes go to the IRS with every paycheck. You can pay yourself every two weeks if you like. We do it monthly because it's simpler. Your CPA can run payroll for you, often for $60–$100 a month. We do it ourselves, which means Mrs. TFC does it.
Quarterly, we pay estimated state and federal taxes. Our CPA gives us the amounts at the start of the year and we adjust at tax time. Whatever is left after the tax payment, we take as a distribution, free of FICA.
Keep enough in the business account to cover the next payroll and any expenses you're waiting to be reimbursed for, like housing, flights and hotels. Watch your cash flow, too. I'm usually paid every Friday, but a few weeks of vacation means a few weeks with no check. Welcome to the 1099 life.
Yearly, the cycle looks like this:
January to April: no big distributions. I save like a squirrel in case we owe in April.
April and May: the tax bill gets paid. Leftover money and any refund fund both of our Solo 401(k)s, two backdoor Roth IRAs and our HSA.
June to December: distributions flow through us personally and into our brokerage account. Those are after-tax dollars we can use whenever we want. That's what makes early retirement possible, and every dollar in the brokerage account loosens the golden handcuffs one more notch.
Even as a new grad, pay quarterly taxes. Every year I see posts asking how someone ended up with a $75,000 tax bill. The first question is always whether they paid quarterly. The answer is always no. Tell your CPA your rate, your expected weeks and your expected monthly income, and pay conservatively. A small underpayment carries only a small penalty. Skipping quarterly payments altogether is how you end up with that $75,000 bill.
The setup was stressful. Once it's running, it's straightforward. Small, regular adjustments with your CPA are all it takes. Fair warning, though: going back to W-2 afterward is a real pain. Once you've made the switch, it's hard to go back.
Three Moves to Make This Year
Set your salary from real data. Use the AANA survey or BLS wages, and write down why you chose the number this year.
Give yourself a modest raise each year. A couple of percent, the way a hospital system would. It shows a steady pattern rather than a sudden drop.
Run the full tradeoff with your CPA. Payroll tax, audit exposure, Solo 401(k) room and QBI all move with the same number.
The checklist gets you in the door. The reasonable salary keeps you defensible once you're there.
If this helped, follow The Financial Cocktail wherever you get your podcasts and find us on Facebook. Send it to a coworker starting their own 1099 journey. And if you have a take on how you set your S-Corp salary, share it. I'd love this to be a place for that conversation in the CRNA community.
This post is for education only and is not individualized financial, tax or legal advice. It discusses general tax concepts and publicly available IRS guidance. Consult a qualified CPA or attorney before making decisions about your situation.